Conditions / Refusal Reasons
That the proposals would be contrary to the provisions of the
Oxfordshire Structure Plan 2011 and the adopted South Oxfordshire
Local Plan. The site is not allocated for residential development
and its development for 15 dwellings would be contrary to Structure
and Local Plan policies for restraint in the District (SP G1, H1;
SOLP G1, G3). Sufficient land has already been allocated to ensure
that the housing provisions in the Structure and Local Plan can be
met and this development would result in these provisions being
exceeded contrary to Policy H1 of the adopted South Oxfordshire Local
Plan. The proposals are contrary to Policy H5 of the adopted
South Oxfordshire Local Plan in that this is not strict infill
development, which is defined as filling of an appropriate small gap
in an otherwise built up frontage, and the proposal to erect 15
dwellings would detract from the character of this small village.
That the proposals are contrary to the Conservation policies in the
adopted South Oxfordshire Local Plan (CON7, 8, 9, 10). This farmyard
contributes to the setting of the adjacent listed building, Town Farm
House, and to the character of the Lewknor Conservation Area such that
the development of the site by 15 dwellings will detract from its
setting and from the character and appearance of the Lewknor
Conservation Area.
In addition the proposals would result in the loss of an attractive
early 19th Century brick barn which contributes to the setting of the
adjoining listed building, Town Farm House, and the character and
appearance of the Lewknor Conservation Area.
Notwithstanding refusal reason 1, the proposal fails to provide an
element of affordable housing in accordance with Policy H7 of the
adopted South Oxfordshire Local Plan.