Planning Application Details

P16/S3525/FULApplication Type: Full Application (Show Map - opens in new window)
Status Bar
 
 Completed stage
 
 Current stage
 
 Next stage
Application registered
Consultation period
Application under consideration
Decision made
Description
Redevelopment to form 41 sheltered apartments for the elderly, including communal facilities, access, car parking and landscaping.
Location
Thames Valley Police Greyhound Lane THAME OX9 3ZD
Grid Reference
470664/206131
Applicant
Churchill Retirement Living
Millstream House
Parkside
Ringwood
BH24 3SG
Agent
Planning Issues Limited
Millstream House
Parkside
RINGWOOD
BH24 3SG
Constraints
Thame Conservation Area
Case Officer
Phil Moule
Telephone: 01235 422600
Email: planning@southoxon.gov.uk
View officers committee report (05/04/2017) here
Consultation / Notification
No further Representations on this application will be accepted.

Consultations / Notifications to date are shown below.

Name / Number
Date Sent
Response Date
 
106 Officer
02 11 2016
 
Community Infrastructure Officer
02 11 2016
 
Community Infrastructure Officer (South)
02 11 2016
 
Community Infrastructure Officer (Vale)
02 11 2016
 
Conservation Officer ( South )
02 11 2016
23 11 2016
 
Countryside Officer(South Oxfordshire & Vale of White Horse)
02 11 2016
23 11 2016
 
Drainage Engineer (South Oxfordshire - MONSON)
02 11 2016
27 11 2016
 
Economic Development
02 11 2016
 
Forestry Officer (South Oxfordshire District Council)
02 11 2016
28 11 2016
 
Health & Housing - Air Quality
08 02 2017
27 02 2017
 
Health & Housing - Contaminated Land
01 11 2016
15 11 2016
 
Health & Housing - Env. Protection Team
08 02 2017
07 03 2017
 
Housing Development
02 11 2016
 
Oxfordshire County Council Single Response
20 12 2016
30 01 2017
 
Oxfordshire Primary Care (South Oxfordshire DC)
02 11 2016
 
Planning Enforcement Team
02 11 2016
08 11 2016
 
Thame Cons.Area Advisory Comm.
03 11 2016
 
Thame Cons.Area Advisory Comm.
01 11 2016
03 11 2016
 
Thame Town Council
c/o Mr Graham Hunt
Town Hall
High Street
THAME
Oxon
OX9 3DP
02 11 2016
22 11 2016
 
Thames Water Development Control
02 11 2016
16 11 2016
 
Urban Design Officer (South Oxon & Vale of White Horse DC)
02 11 2016
 
1 Willow Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3BE
30 03 2017
 
10 Pym Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TA
30 03 2017
 
11 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
12 Berkeley Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TN
30 03 2017
 
13 Pym Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TA
30 03 2017
 
14 Willow Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3BE
30 03 2017
 
15 Greenway
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3BG
30 03 2017
 
15 Pym Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TA
30 03 2017
 
16 Denbigh Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TL
30 03 2017
 
16 Pym Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TA
30 03 2017
 
16 Webster Close
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TU
30 03 2017
 
21 Webster Close
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TU
30 03 2017
 
23 Moorend Lane
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3BQ
30 03 2017
 
27 Lambert Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3DT
30 03 2017
 
27 Pym Walk
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TA
30 03 2017
 
3 Skippon Way
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3DW
30 03 2017
 
30 Webster Close
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TU
30 03 2017
 
35 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
36 Webster Close
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TU
30 03 2017
 
39 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
40 Berkeley Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TN
30 03 2017
 
41 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
5 Brookside
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3DE
30 03 2017
 
5 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
5 Chalgrove Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TF
30 03 2017
 
59 Berkeley Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TN
30 03 2017
 
63 Berkeley Road
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TN
30 03 2017
 
7 Campbell Close
Hitchin
SG4 0RH
30 03 2017
 
7 Greenway
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3BG
30 03 2017
 
7 Webster Close
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3TU
30 03 2017
 
9 Naseby Close
Thame
OX9 3WA
29 03 2017
 
Fore Golf
10 Buttermarket
Thame
Oxfordshire
OX9 3EW
03 12 2016
 
4 Bell Close, Thame
OX9 3AN
30 11 2016
 
27 Pickenfield
Thame
OX9 3HG
28 11 2016
 
4 Pickenfield
Thame
Oxon
OX9 3HG
25 11 2016
 
11 Nelson Street, Thame
OX9 2DP
24 11 2016
 
24 High Street
Thame
OX9 2BZ
24 11 2016
 
39 North Street
Thame
OX9 3BJ
01 11 2016
24 11 2016
 
New House
Bell Lane
Thame
Oxon
OX93AL
24 11 2016
 
63 Ormond Road, Thame
OX9 3XN
23 11 2016
 
A Patterson - via email
23 11 2016
 
The White Lodge, 15 King'S Road
Thame
OX9 3JJ
23 11 2016
 
1 Fanshawe Road
Thame
Oxfordshire
OX9 3LF
22 11 2016
 
1 Fanshawe Road, Thame
OX9 3LF
22 11 2016
 
17b Swan Gardens, Tetsworth
Thame
OX9 7BN
22 11 2016
 
27 High Street
Brill
HP18 9ST
22 11 2016
 
5 Elmtrees
Long Crendon
Aylesbury
Buckinghamshire
HP189DG
22 11 2016
 
5 Hunt Road, Thame
OX9 3LG
22 11 2016
 
9 WYKEHAM GATE
HADDENHAM
AYLESBURY
BUCKS
HP17 8DF
22 11 2016
 
Mrs Trueman- Via email
22 11 2016
 
Pollicott Barn
Upper Pollicott
Ashendon
Aylesbury
Bucks
HP18 0HH
22 11 2016
 
The Old Barn, Bell Lane
Thame
OX9 3AL
22 11 2016
 
The Stables, Bell Lane
Thame
OX9 3AL
22 11 2016
 
consulted by email
22 11 2016
 
1 Naseby Close, Thame
OX9 3WA
21 11 2016
 
12 Putman Close, Thame
OX9 3LD
21 11 2016
 
17 Lambert Walk, Thame
OX9 3DT
21 11 2016
 
3P Kite Wing
 
Appeals
 
Petals
Greyhound Lane
Thame
OX9 3ZD
01 11 2016
 
Thames Valley Police
Greyhound Lane
Thame
OX9 3ZD
01 11 2016
 
Waitrose Ltd
Greyhound Lane
Thame
OX9 3ZD
01 11 2016
 
xx
 
xx
 
xx
 
Application Type
Major (Full Application)
Application Progress
Date Received  
21st October 2016
Registration Date  
21st October 2016
Start Consultation Period  
1st November 2016
End Consultation Period  
31st January 2017
Target Decision Date  
30th March 2017
Target Committee Meeting  
5th April 2017
Decision
Refusal of Planning Permission on 19th April 2017
Conditions / Refusal Reasons
The proposal fails to provide an adequate level of off-street parking for the proposed use, which would lead to the displacement of parking associated with the proposed development onto nearby roads and public car parking facilities. This would have a detrimental impact on the vibrancy of Thame town centre. This is contrary to Policy T2 of the South Oxfordshire Local Plan 2011, Policy GA6 of the Thame Neighbourhood Plan and paragraphs 39 and 40 of the National Planning Policy Framework. Related application(s): P18/S3700/DIS, P19/S0266/DIS, P19/S4290/DIS, P20/S0280/DIS, P20/S3669/DIS

The proposal would result in an overdevelopment of the site which is demonstrated by the inadequacy of car parking provision and the lack of high quality and usable amenity space being provided for future occupiers. This is contrary to Policy CSQ3 of the South Oxfordshire Core Strategy, Policies D3 and T2 of the South Oxfordshire Local Plan and Policies GA6 and EDSQ28 of the Thame Neighbourhood Plan and Paragraph 17 of the National Planning Policy Framework. Related application(s): P18/S3700/DIS, P19/S0266/DIS, P19/S4290/DIS

Having regard to the bulk, height, massing and design of the proposal in this prominent location, the scheme would fail to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of the Thame Conservation Area. Furthermore, the loss of the existing building itself would constitute an unattractive gap in the Conservation Area and without an approved replacement building, demolition would not preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. This is contrary to Policies CON6 and CON7 of the South Oxfordshire Local Plan 2011, Policies CSTHA1 and CSQ3 of the South Oxfordshire Core Strategy 2012, Policies ESDQ16, ESDQ17, ESDQ18 and ESDQ20 of the Thame Neighbourhood Plan and Paragraphs 17 and 137 of the National Planning Policy Framework. Related application(s): P18/S3700/DIS, P19/S0266/DIS, P19/S3243/DIS

In the absence of a completed S106 planning obligation, the proposal fails to provide affordable housing on-site or an appropriate commuted sum in accordance with Policy CSH3 of the adopted Core Strategy 2012. The proposal also fails to provide adequate on and off site infrastructure and services in accordance with Policy CSI1 of the South Oxfordshire Core Strategy 2012 and paragraph 17 of the National Planning Policy Framework.
Appeal
Appeal Allowed on 28 September 2018
Appeal Case Officer
Phil Moule
Telephone: 01235 422600
Email: planning@southoxon.gov.uk
Updates
These Planning Application Details were returned live from our back office database, and as such are as up to date as when the page was retrieved.